If your roof is starting to show signs of wear such as missing shingles, small leaks, or curling edges, you may be wondering whether to reshingle or get a full roof replacement. Both options can make your home look better and stay protected, but they’re very different in cost, lifespan, and what they involve. Knowing the difference and choosing the right service provider such as Cover All Exteriors helps you pick the right choice for your home and budget.
Benefits of Reshingling
Reshingling, or a roof overlay, means putting a new layer of shingles over your existing roof. There’s no full tear off, which makes the project faster and easier.
- Lower upfront cost: No need to remove old shingles, so labor and disposal costs are smaller.
- Faster installation: With fewer steps, the job usually takes less time.
- Less mess: Since the old roof stays, there’s less debris and noise.
Reshingling works best if your roof has only one layer of shingles and the structure underneath is still solid. It can improve the look of your roof and give it a few more years of life without the expense of a full replacement. Reshingling also doesn’t fix hidden problems. If there’s rot, leaks, or damage under the old shingles, it won’t be addressed. Adding a second layer also adds weight to your roof, which isn’t ideal for every home. The lifespan of a reshingle job is usually shorter than a full replacement. This option is often good for homeowners who want a quick, lower cost fix or plan to sell their home soon.
Benefits of Full Replacement
A full roof replacement means removing all old shingles down to the decking base. This lets the contractor check the roof structure, fix any damage, and install new underlayment and shingles.
- Fixes hidden issues: Any rot, leaks, or damage gets repaired.
- Lasts longer: A new roof lasts much longer than an overlay.
- Better protection: New underlayment and ventilation improve performance.
- Increases home value: A brand new roof makes your home look better and is a selling point for buyers.
While it costs more and takes longer, a full roof replacement gives you long term protection and less chance of repairs in the near future. It’s an investment in your home.
Reshingling may be a good choice if your roof is still in good condition, there’s only one layer of shingles, and you want a lower cost, faster fix. Full replacement is better if your roof is older or has multiple layers, there are recurring leaks or visible damage, the structure under the shingles is weak, or you plan to stay in your home long term. Neglecting small leaks can also lead to mold growth around your home. Choosing between reshingling and full replacement isn’t just about cost. It’s about keeping your home safe and avoiding future problems. A professional roof inspection can show whether your decking and shingles are in good shape. This helps you know if a simple overlay will work or if a full replacement is needed.
Reshingling can save money upfront, but a full replacement fixes hidden damage, lasts longer, and gives peace of mind. The goal for both is to protect your home and family while getting the best product for your money. Choosing the right option now keeps your roof strong, safe, and looking good for years to come. For more information and a free quote, contact Cover All Exteriors today and speak with one of our experts.